Independent cigar reference
Est. 2026
Maker's Choice Vanilla
MAKER'S CHOICE
Vanilla
SHORT PANATELA
Cigarbench score
83 / 100
5 reviews on record.
Reviews
5
on record
Price
$1.20
Average, per stick.
An unsourced average, not a live quote.
average
Elevation · actual size
5″ × 36 short panatela · Dominican Republic filler · mild-medium strength
I · The blend
FillerDominican Republic
OriginDominican Republic
ColourNaturale
StrengthMild-Medium
II · What people taste
Counted words in the 5 reviews we hold. Never a quote, never our opinion.
vanillanamed in 5 of 5 reviews100%
sweetnamed in 3 of 5 reviews60%
bitternamed in 2 of 5 reviews40%
spicenamed in 2 of 5 reviews40%
earthnamed in 1 of 5 reviews20%
smoothnamed in 1 of 5 reviews20%
III · The rest of the Maker's Choice house
The score blends 5 reviews from every source we hold, shrunk toward the mean so a cigar with three reviews cannot outrank one with three hundred. How the score is built
Price is one retailer's per-stick quote, not an average, and it is not live.
We do not judge plume or mould from a photo, and we do not tell you when a cigar is ready. Read r/cigars' pinned guide for that.