Independent cigar reference
Est. 2026

Caldwell Cigar Co. Blind Man's Bluff Maduro Magnum

CALDWELL CIGAR CO.
Blind Man's Bluff Maduro Magnum
TORO GORDO

Cigarbench score

Not rated

2 reviews on record.
Under 5, so no score is claimed.

Reviews

2

on record

Price

$7.80

Per stick, one retailer.
Not an average. One snapshot, not live.

per stick

Elevation · actual size
6″60 RG

6″ × 60 toro gordo · Pennsylvania wrapper · Sumatra binder · Dominican Republic filler · medium-full strength

I · The blend

WrapperPennsylvania
BinderSumatra
FillerDominican Republic
OriginDominican Republic
ColourMaduro
StrengthMedium-Full

II · Cheaper than this

Matched on size, shape, strength and a trustworthy score. Not a taste claim. Only cigars with 20 or more reviews are listed.

A.J. Fernandez New World Cameroon Double Robusto5.5″ × 54 · Cameroon · medium-full · 84 reviews5.5″ × 54 · Nicaragua · medium-full$6.7513% less · 88El Rey del Mundo Robusto Larga (Oscuro)6″ × 54 · Connecticut Broadleaf · medium-full · 75 reviews6″ × 54 · Honduras · medium-full$7.405% less · 88Cigars International CI Legends Series Don Pepin Garcia - Yellow5.7″ × 54 · Corojo · Nicaragua · medium-full · 26 reviews5.7″ × 54 · Nicaragua · medium-full$1.6079% less · 88La Gloria Cubana Serie N JSB5.5″ × 54 · Ecuador · Sumatra · medium-full · 21 reviews5.5″ × 54 · Nicaragua · medium-full$3.5854% less · 885 Vegas Series A Apotheosis5.5″ × 55 · Costa Rica · medium-full · 21 reviews5.5″ × 55 · Nicaragua · medium-full$2.5567% less · 87

III · The rest of the Caldwell Cigar Co. house

The King Is Dead Premier5.5″ × 50 · Dominican Republic · medium$11.65Eastern Standard Corretto5″ × 50 · Brazil · Connecticut Shade · Ecuador · mild-medium$12.80Long Live The King Petit Dbl Wide Short Churchill6″ × 52 · Corojo · Dominican Republic · full$13.80Long Live The King Marquis6″ × 60 · Corojo · Dominican Republic · full$14.80Eastern Standard (Dark Connecticut) Cypress Room6″ × 54 · Connecticut · Ecuador · mild-medium$15.75

A score needs at least 5 reviews before we print one. How the score is built
Price is one retailer's per-stick quote, not an average, and it is not live.
We do not judge plume or mould from a photo, and we do not tell you when a cigar is ready. Read r/cigars' pinned guide for that.