Independent cigar reference
Est. 2026

J.C. Newman The American Toro

J.C. NEWMAN
The American Toro
TORO
87

Cigarbench score

87 / 100

30 reviews on record.
Most gave it the top mark.

Reviews

30

on record

Price

$22.00

Per stick, one retailer.
Listed out of stock. One snapshot, not live.

per stick

Elevation · actual size
6″54 RG

6″ × 54 toro · United States wrapper · Connecticut Broadleaf binder · Connecticut, Pennsylvania filler · medium strength

I · The blend

WrapperUnited States
BinderConnecticut Broadleaf
FillerConnecticut, Pennsylvania
OriginUnited States
ColourColorado Maduro
StrengthMedium

II · Cheaper than this

Matched on size, shape, strength and a trustworthy score. Not a taste claim. Only cigars with 20 or more reviews are listed.

EP Carrillo Encore Celestial6″ × 50 · Nicaraguan · medium · 65 reviews6″ × 50 · Dominican Republic · medium$13.0041% less · 91Room 101 Johnny Tobacconaut Toro6″ × 52 · Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade · medium · 22 reviews6″ × 52 · Nicaragua · medium$10.2553% less · 91EP Carrillo Allegiance Wingman Double Corona6″ × 54 · Ecuadorian Sumatra-Seed · medium · 21 reviews6″ × 54 · Nicaragua · medium$13.7038% less · 91Drew Estate Tabak Especial Toro Dulce6″ × 52 · Connecticut Shade · medium · 123 reviews6″ × 52 · Nicaragua · medium$10.6052% less · 90Plasencia Alma Del Campo Guajiro5.5″ × 54 · Nicaragua · medium · 67 reviews5.5″ × 54 · Nicaragua · medium$19.0014% less · 90

III · The rest of the J.C. Newman house

The American Churchill7″ × 48 · United States · medium$23.00Yagua6″ × 54 · Connecticut Broadleaf · full$11.50The American Robusto4.5″ × 50 · United States · medium$18.50Angel Cuesta Toro6.25″ × 52 · Ecuador · Habano$22.00The American Double Robusto5.5″ × 56 · United States · full$21.00

The score blends 30 reviews from every source we hold, shrunk toward the mean so a cigar with three reviews cannot outrank one with three hundred. How the score is built
Price is one retailer's per-stick quote, not an average, and it is not live.
We do not judge plume or mould from a photo, and we do not tell you when a cigar is ready. Read r/cigars' pinned guide for that.